Counterfeits and Material Difference: What’s the Difference?

Would it matter to you if a seller has not been trained in the proper storage and quality control of a product? I would want to know that.

In the aftermarket industry, there is a lot of discussion about counterfeits, and these discussions are usually pretty unpleasant. If unchecked, counterfeits can destroy brand value not to mention decrease legitimate sales. Counterfeits are clearly inferior to the products they are copying, right? But there is a time when “materially different” products can be a good thing and can actually lead to higher sales and greater brand value.

What I’m talking about is another kind of material difference. Not actually a difference in the materials, but a legal material difference. This type of material difference can be used to your advantage, and can assist cleaning up sales channels, as well as helping to eliminate actual counterfeits.

First, what is the legal definition of a “material difference”? The best and most concise definition I’ve found is: “Any difference that a consumer would consider relevant when purchasing a product.”

This would be a great time to point out that I am NOT an attorney and nothing I say should be taken as legal advice. But that being said, I do spend much of my life reading and researching these things.

So, what does this kind of material difference look like in non-legal terms? To answer that question, all we need to do is think about what kind of difference would matter to a us, if we were buying a product.

Would it matter to you if a seller has not been trained in the proper storage and quality control of a product? I would want to know that.

What about being on a recall list? If a seller I bought from was unaware of potential problems with the product I was buying, I would certainly want to know that.

And my favorite, what if the awesome gear I bought did not come with a manufacturer warranty, even though it looked identical to ones that do come with a warranty? That is sure as hell something I would find relevant!

You can see how these types of “material differences” would matter to us, as consumers, but do you know who else thinks they are relevant? Amazon.

Amazon, with all the issues they create for MAP enforcement, does do one thing very well. They focus on customer experience. And this focus on customer experience is probably the primary factor in their continued growth. If Amazon customers buy products without warranties, or that are materially different in other ways, without realizing it, they can get pretty pissed off. It is this pissed off attitude from Amazon that helps manufacturers clean up their brands.

When a brand asks Amazon to remove a seller because they are violating Minimum Advertised Price (MAP) policies, all you will hear from Amazon is crickets. They just don’t care. In fact, if customers are getting a better price, Amazon sees that as a better customer experience, not a worse one. So, they are not about to do anything to help you.

If on the other hand, their customers are getting “materially different” products and are unhappy they are much more open to stepping in. Now, suddenly your priorities and Amazon’s are aligned.

Learning to create these material differences, without creating too much internal hassle is a fine balance, but it can be used to great effect. Anything that aligns your priorities with that of a behemoth like Amazon has to be good, right?

So, how does this help deal with actual counterfeits, you might be asking? Well, if you remove the fringe sellers who are selling the fakes, you keep the counterfeits out of the marketplace! And it is much easier to do by focusing on the good sellers and making sure they are the only ones selling than trying to identify all the bad apples. Plus, it is much better for your mental state.  

If you have any questions, please reach out to me at [email protected], or visit us at mapservicescorp.com.

You May Also Like

Popular Snowmobile Accessories

Which accessories will customers need before they even leave the showroom with their new sleds?

snowmobile, accessories

Last week, we published an article from Arctic Cat about how to help customers find the right snowmobiles for them, looking at everything from the buyer’s preferred terrain to his or her ability level in order to determine the proper engine and chassis size.

Now, while it’s no secret that stock snowmobiles are getting more advanced as the years go by, there will always be opportunities to enhance them and the rider’s experience. Let’s take a look at the various accessories that can enhance snowmobile performance, protection, rider comfort and storage capabilities.

Choosing the Right Snowmobile

Help your customers know which sleds are right for them.

Arctic Cat, Snowmobiles, Mountain
Gift Ideas for Riders

Help your customers find the right gifts this season.

gift, motorcycle, Santa hat
Tips for Selling Exhaust Systems

Customers have different reasons for wanting to buy; make sure you know the right product to recommend.

motorcycles, exhaust systems, dealership
Emissions, Heat and Noise Reduction in Exhaust Systems

There are some things you don’t want coming out of your pipes.

motorcycle exhaust, pipes, noise reduction

Other Posts

Destination Dealership: Savannah Motorsports

Savannah Motorsports describes itself as a “small, hometown dealership,” but customers are willing to travel the extra miles from all over the Southeast thanks to the dealership’s can-do, friendly attitude.

Dealing with Multi-Generational Dealership Employees

Understanding generational gaps and differences is part of working on the business. How are you dealing with it?

Have You Added One Brand Too Many?

Think twice or even three times about adding additional brands to an already successful dealership.

Motorcycle business, background, motorcycle showroom, blurry abstract, blurred background and can be an illustration of motorcycle parking articles
Exhaust System Builds, Materials and Developments

Depending on the application, a motorcycle or powersport exhaust system’s makeup will impact function and performance.

motorcycle, exhaust system, pipes