Should I Replace the Black Box?

Unfortunately, black boxes often unnecessarily take the blame for mysterious electrical or running condition problems.

Computer, igniter, CDI, ICM, ECU and ECM are all names for the black boxes that are the brains behind modern engines. Depending on their type, they control ignition, fuel injection, ABS, display meter or a combination of all. They are very important and often very expensive. Unfortunately, they often unnecessarily take the blame for mysterious electrical or running condition problems.

At Cyclepedia.com, we provide technical support to motorcycle, scooter and ATV owners who have online service manual subscriptions as well as professional service departments or technicians who have our PRO subscription. Periodically, we receive phone calls or support tickets from mechanics, shade-tree and professionals, who have become frustrated by a vehicle’s puzzling problem and have decided the black box is faulty. They think problem is mysterious, the black box is mysterious and that must be the cause of the problem.

In most cases, there are not diagnostic procedures for black boxes themselves. If you are lucky, the manufacturer might specify some output voltages or resistance figures. The last line of an ignition troubleshooting chart is often, “Faulty ECM – replace with a known good unit.” That statement is assuming that everything else on the vehicle is functioning correctly, not that there is a damaged wire in the harness you haven’t caught yet.

Replacing the black box is a last result option. They are very rarely the cause of the problem. They should only be replaced once all other issues have been ruled out – not just testing the obvious components, but carefully inspecting the wiring harness, connectors, grounds and switches. Don’t get too fixated on one component or one system. Have an open mind. Take a break and come back to the problem if possible.

All too often we hear from folks who have become frustrated and declared they have a faulty box on there hands. Hopefully, they sought further advice before wasting a wad of money. The worst case is the person has jumped the gun and bought a new box. Often, other electrical components have the same problem.

The following is a list of the true faults behind some suspected bad black boxes Cyclepedia has helped out with over the years:

  • gear position switch
  • reverse override switch
  • engine kill switch
  • ignition switch
  • side stand switch
  • bad ground
  • wire harness damage
  • poorly installed aftermarket components
  • fouled spark plug

In all the years of working on powersports vehicles, the collective staff at Cyclepedia has only encountered two true faulty black boxes. The first was an ignition box that was damaged by being unplugged and plugged back in while powered. Never unplug or plug in this type of component while the circuits are powered. The second was an ECM that emitted smoke and a black liquid that smelled of an electrical fire when the main switch was turned on. Further research showed that this component should have been replaced years ago by an OEM recall.

Link: Cyclepedia

You May Also Like

Proper Exhaust System Care

Keeping it clean is simple, but when is it time to repack?

mechanic, muffler, engine, exhaust system, maintenance

It’s a point of pride to keep a motorcycle tuned and gleaming. While there isn’t a ton of work that goes into keeping the exhaust system maintained, it’s important to know how best to clean it and when to repack the muffler.

Clean, Dry and Shiny

Safety Systems in Modern Motorcycles

Racing has paved the way for new rider aids in consumer bikes.

motorcycle, concept, sports bike, safety systems
Proper Motorcycle Tire Maintenance and Care

Maintaining proper tire pressure is a common maintenance issue.

motorcycle tires, maintenance, tire pressure, tire pressure monitor
Pre-Season Motorcycle Maintenance Checklist

After sitting all winter, bikes need an inspection before hitting the road.

motorcycle maintenance
Two-Stroke Engine Tech Has a Future

As hybrid vehicles continue to be on the rise, the two-stroke engine might have a comeback.

two-stroke engine

Other Posts

Ep. 82: Supercharged Motorcycles, New Bikes Coming to the U.S. and Spy Photos

We’ve got the scoop on what new bikes are coming.

OTT 82
Financial and Liability Impacts of Safety Recalls

The more information you have, the more reliable your gut instincts will be.

motorcycle, money, profitability, safety recalls
Tips and Techniques from Lucas Oil to Keep Vehicles and More Protected During the Cold

Supercars, motorcycles, hot rods and even riding lawn mowers all have engine oil systems, fuel systems, transmissions and other components that require winter prep.

Lucas Oil
Are You Missing Safety Recalls?

Lower liability means more revenue.

motorcycle, concept, modern, parts, safety recalls