F&I Shop Talk: Turning a Profit Isn’t a Crime… Perhaps

I’ve learned in dealing with powersport dealers that they resent being compared to auto dealers. I could respect that. Until this past trip. I’ll change the names and locations but leave the details intact.

I’ve learned in dealing with powersport dealers that they resent being compared to auto dealers. I could respect that. Until this past trip. I’ll change the names and locations but leave the details intact.

Story No. 1 We were contacted by the dealer as he had concerns regarding pressure he was receiving to make sure he was compliant with his customers throughout the sales process. Initially, when we spoke, he was of the mind to just install some “stuff” and that way he would be compliant. I had to explain (and it took a while) that having software is not what makes you compliant. He argued a bit and then thought about whether this would be worth the hassle.

Story No. 2 Same trip different dealer. This dealer was also interested in compliance but also wanted to be able to track his staff’s performance. When we were demonstrating the software, the sales manager was always “busy.” After the install, and while we were in the dealership, the manager took me aside to ask some questions. The first thing he wanted to know was how to hide certain things. I had an idea what he meant but wanted to be absolutely certain. I asked him to explain.

He made it perfectly clear. All he wanted the customer to see was monthly payments. No price, just payments. Those payments were to be at the maximum interest allowed by law and any product available was to be packed in the payments. He was inflating the price without sharing that with the customer. Then, he asked if I “understood” where he was coming from.

I did. When I told him that the dealer was installing this software to make sure the customers were totally clear on what they were getting, his reply was just as clear. “There is no way any software is going to give me a cut in pay. I can promise you that this software will be broken every day until it’s taken out of here.”

One story was a bit longer than the other, but both had the same objective. The dealer and/or his representative wanted to make the most money from every customer (which is the way business should be) regardless of what rules had to be bent or broken (not the way business should be). The sad truth is, I looked at both of these dealers’ numbers. Here’s what I found.

In both cases, gross, F&I penetration and PVR were about average for that part of the country. It’s obvious their tactics weren’t making them any extra money per deal compared to the competition. What it probably was doing was making it easier for their competition to get some of their business. The reason is simple. Packing payments or other tricks to make gross, only work when you’re selling the customer on the spot. If that customer leaves and gets treated to an honest sales process somewhere else, they’ll never go back to that dealer. Besides, that’s exactly what every car dealer was doing until the mid-1990s.

What’s the Solution?

Actually, it’s not all that complicated. Start from the customer side. How many of your customers have been on the internet before they get to your showroom? Statistically, almost all of them. If that’s true, how much information is available online about the unit, the pricing, financing, etc.? EVERYTHING.

Then, why on God’s green earth would you think that working like a car dealer from the 1980s would be a better way to do business? All you have to do is read the auto industry publications to see how that’s working. Yes, there are still some dealers who let their managers operate like it’s 1989. They’re being fined in the hundreds of thousands of dollars and being forced to refund customers equal amounts. Just last week a dealership was fined over $900,000. To put that into perspective, we service powersport dealers who would like to reach that number for gross profit annually.

Progressive and highly profitable dealers have found the secret to increasing profits by a minimum of 20 percent. You see, having compliant software isn’t enough. You need to have a process behind it. Not having a process is like buying a hammer and nails, laying them on your showroom floor and coming back in a week and expecting an office to be built.

Dealers who realize that the customer is fully informed can use that to increase profits. The reason is, rather than getting mysterious or defensive, they can simply agree with the customer and present them facts and figures to do business with them today. But, the real benefit is, the right process can eliminate the “I’m just looking” buyer from your showroom and turn them into deliveries.

So, saying you don’t want to be compared to car dealers isn’t enough. You need to do the things that make for a successful powersports operation that wants happy customers. Happy customers always pay higher profits, purchase more F&I products and, best of all, come back in a few years to do it all again.

John Fuhrman is director of training for OptionSoft Technologies. To learn more, email him at [email protected].

You May Also Like

Building an Employee-to-Company Relationship

In the relationship between an employee and a company, the makeup of that is more than just what we are paying them.

dealership employees

How do you keep your employees happy? Is it with random lunches and breakfast? Is it with awards and employee-of-the-month plaques? I believe those things can help, but they shouldn’t be the foundation of a relationship between an employee and the company. 

There is so much talk about building trust between management and employees. How to give feedback and when to invest in your staff. All of this is even more stressful because base wages are rising, and it can feel like a rat race to keep everyone happy, yet no one seems to be winning. 

Dealerships Shouldn’t Say, ‘I Don’t Know’

Every staff member can’t know everything. I certainly don’t know everything, but to say, “I don’t know,” is inexcusable.

Dealer Dialogue with Broward Motorsports of Palm Beach

This sizable dealership caters to just about every powersports segment you can think of.

Broward Motorsports
At Greenville Motor Sports, Hunting and Farming Vehicles Thrive

Family-owned and -operated, Greenville Motor Sports is the go-to destination in the Mississippi Delta for powersports needs.

Greenville Motor Sports
NPA Pre-Owned Market Update: April 2024

New and used sales look very similar to 2023.

National Powersport Auctions, NPA, Market Report
Other Posts
Segway Powersports Launches Full Send Summer Savings Promotion

Segway Powersports’s program with Octane offers 0% APR for 36 months or up to $3,500 rebate on select models.

Boundless Rider Launches Safe Rider Program

The Safe Rider Program utilizes AI-powered crash detection technology to provide real-time emergency response coordination.

Boundless Rider logo
NYC Norton Is Vintage Racing Paradise

Kenny Cummings, the owner of NYC Norton, doesn’t want his exact location in Jersey City, NJ, disclosed. But, inside, it’s a vintage Norton and racing heaven.

Kenny Cummings NYC Norton
How Dealers Can Manage the Bloat From Growth

There are four things to add to your “beat the bloat checklist.” This advice applies if you run a department or own the dealership.